Red Team + Blue Team · one evidence layer

Compare

The Blue Team compares pass-market and fail-market TWAPs with each proposal’s threshold. The Red Team checks for versioned attack indicators. Their findings stay separate, and each classification applies only to the vector shown.

Comparing 5 protocols.

Light blue bars on the pass-edge chart are the pass threshold. Select one or more protocols — charts redraw from published pass/fail TWAPs, treasury snapshots, and vector-scoped economic attack indicators.

Comparison charts

Treasury value (source-dated)

MetaDAO $11.78M Avici $2.73M Solomon $5.77M Umbra $2.48M Loyal $0.34M

Premium / discount to NAV

MetaDAO 856.10% Avici 104.30% Solomon -9.50% Umbra 45.50% Loyal -16.40%

Pass edge vs threshold

UmbraLoyal

Economic attack indicators

Umbra 5

Volume alignment

UmbraLoyal

Fail-by margin

Umbra 19.55% Loyal -1.00%

Selected protocols